Walk the Line - A Commentary
I finally got to watch the movie "Walk the Line" starring Joaquin Phoenix as Johnny Cash, and Reese Witherspoon as June Carter. They are both great actors and I think Witherspooon deserve her Academy award for Best Actress (I'm also saying this because she's always been one of my favourite actresses).
*stop reading...following is a spoiler of the movie...*
My commentary today is not so much about how well they sang or how well they act, but the question of love. In the movie, Johnny is a married man with kids when he first met June, who is also married. Because of Johnny's wife's lack of interest in his career (and have more interest in building the perfect home/family), Johnny falls in love with June, who shares a very similar family background, passion for music, inner demons, etc... At the same time, as June was going through a difficult time through her divorce, rejections from her community, etc... she helplessly falls in love with Johnny. June's determination in doing the right thing, i.e. resisting Johnny on his many attempts of advances, drives Johnny down the road of drugs and alcohol, abandoning his wife and kids, destroying his career, losing his passion for his music - the road to self-destruction. Johnny Cash was relentless in his pursuit for June Carter.
Now, the problem that I have with this movie is this - Johnny acts as if love is everything and can justify one to do whatever you want in order to give your love to another woman. So what if your wife is not interested in your career a whole lot and is self absorbed, you're still married to her and hence you are still responsible for her and the kids. Just because you fall in love with another woman, it doesn't mean that you can deliberately hurt your wife like that. You can't just hurt your wife and kids, destroy you and your bandmates' careers, abuse drugs, feeling sorry for yourself, etc... just because the woman you love chooses not to be with you. While it seems to be a sacrificial kind of love at the surface, in my opinion, Johnny doesn't know how to love.
On the other hand, I have a lot of admiration for June Carter. She is sensible and she stays away from Johnny whenever she detects something from Johnny's end. She has such strong mind that though she loves Johnny, she does right thing to do at the right time (most of the time). She knows when to shun him down, when to rebuke, when to help, and most importantly, when to forgive. When Johnny is doubting his self worth, June reminds him, "God is giving you a second chance." Maybe because it is a matter of the heart, June loves Johnny even when it hurts like hell and even when it doesn't make sense.
I really don't think Johnny deserves June. Johnny Cash is not a good man, no matter how talented he is, but that's just my opinion.
The concern that I have with this movie is that the society tend to appreciate the way Johnny loves June than June's love for John. These days, the society (as least to me) seems to celebrate the kind of love that is self-destructing and irresponsible. It seems such a self-less act to give up your family, your career, etc... just because you found someone whom you desire so much. The truth is, as we grow up, we carry responsibilities for ourselves and for others. By abandoning all else just so you can love someone is a selfish act. Period. Unless this is the One who creates you and who redeems you from sins.
While June Carter is an admirable character, I do wonder if I could keep loving someone who hurt himself and me so badly.
All in all, this movie is executed almost flawlessly, but the issue that I have with his love story (like Brokeback Mountain) is that human love alone does not justify one to be irresponsible, foolish and senseless. One must love with his heart and his mind. Lovers out there, this is the balance we all need to learn to strike.

2 Comments:
June Carter, a very adorable and yes admirable character in the movie. Very appreciate how she handles her life, family thru marriage crisis. There's so much pressure on her from the society and it was so unfair, and yet she's holding on and sustain thru. In fact, do we really treasure such kind of good people in this "practical" society? Think we got disappointed easily when we look at others but the more impt thing it do our part. June Carter definitely deserve someone better than Johnny Cash but it's very rare to find someone as match like that in life.
i did not watch the movie. However, in reading your blog, a question did come to mind..."doesn't true love contain an element of abandonement? .... where one throws away everything in pursuit of one's true desire?" while i am not one to advocate irresponsible nor irrational living, i reckon that some level of abandonement is perhaps a true-er reflection of deep affections... afterall, is it not written that "many waters cannot quench love..."
Post a Comment
<< Home